Tuition Free College

My wife, Judy, and I have been talking about the upcoming presidential election. We have both served as college professors and are concerned about higher education. Bernie Sanders has been proposing that college tuition at public schools be made free for all who qualify. The demand for an educated work force has grown exponentially in the last few decades, and the only good jobs currently being created require higher education. Hilary Clinton pointed out, in a recent debate, that a portion of the cash to pay for this program would have to come from the states, and that Republican governors and Republican controlled state legislatures would balk at devoting more money to education.

Perhaps this problem could be resolved by creating federal grants and vouchers for college tuition that would be paid for by the following: 1. Cut health and retirement benefits for U.S. Senators and Representatives. 2. Cut military spending programs for weapons that the Pentagon does not need or want. 3. Eliminate tax breaks and loopholes that allow corporations and multi-millionaires to pay a lower tax rate than middle class, full time workers. 4. Stay out of wars of choice to keep down the national debt—in other words, only go to war when the safety of the United States and select allies is at stake, and conclusively prove the necessity of that choice with hard evidence.

Judy pointed out another problem with the Sanders’ plan: public institutions wouldn’t have the financial means to build new facilities and hire enough professors to withstand the tidal wave of enrollment that would follow.

Schools could raise their standards of admission until enrollment would be limited to a select few.  Colleges would avoid breaking their budgets, but the problem of educating a new generation of workers would remain unsolved. There might be another alternative: why not set up a new, upgraded version of the GI bill and tie free college tuition to two years of service?

The service could be civilian (conservation work, assisting as teachers’ aides in impoverished school districts, elder care assistance, etc.) or military. Needed work to improve the social and physical infrastructure of the nation would get done at a low cost (room and board, initially), and the military would get a deeper pool of recruits.

Some of my recent college students suffer from an inflated sense of entitlement. They expect me to anticipate their unspoken needs minute by minute and seem unaware that they have to ask questions, pay attention and follow directions in order to learn the most and get the best results. If something goes wrong with an assignment they believe that the instructor is at fault, not them. Sometimes they view me as a temporary roadblock to their eventual expression of genius, and that if I simply praised them for the self-evident wonderment of their talents, knowledge and intelligence then everything could proceed according to their plans.

Older students who have served in the military or worked for a living are usually much better. They understand that I work hard to deliver useful information and advice, and they do their best to listen and complete assignments as directed. They’ve matured to the point where they understand that they have to work for success and improvement, and are aware that they may not have reached the upper limits of their talent. They realize that humility and an accurate self-assessment of their abilities are necessary for continued growth.

I believe that if more students were involved in service programs and gained a few years of maturity they would be better able to make the most of a college education. Free education would be a reward for a bit of self-sacrifice. Universities wouldn’t be swamped by a mass of new students as the group receiving subsidized tuition would be self-limiting. Not everyone would be willing to temporarily leave behind the comforts and freedom of a life where few demands are made upon them. The self-indulgent would be left to pay for their continued self-indulgence.



3 thoughts on “Tuition Free College

  1. The same question of free tuition is raised in Canada. Many young people want free tuition and demand that Boomers pay for it because we apparently stole what we have today. I find that many young adults lack maturity today, parents have been around to provide for them and they do not understand the need to make an effort or work hard to get ahead. Not all are like that but there is a significant number and that is worrisome for society’s future.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. My parents grew up during the Depression. They live through hard times and wanted to prepare us for a tough world. They didn’t coddle us, though they probably treated us better than they had been treated. When I went to college the professors demanded that we prove our worth before they bothered to spend time on us. Some wouldn’t even acknowledge a respectful greeting in the hallway. I try to be a lot more forthcoming when I teach and to provide service to everyone according to their need. What I’ve found recently is that a growing percentage of my students don’t believe that I’m giving them enough.

    Liked by 1 person

    • As a docent at the National Gallery of Canada, we get school groups, the most difficult of the 16-20 age group. Many are bored and expect us to amuse them or pretend they understand what they are looking at but have no understanding. I gave a talk last year to graduating students at Ottawa U. on life and work in the Foreign Service. The questions afterwards were interesting, all focused on how to get promoted fast, how much money you could make and lots of complaints on how their inner talent were not recognized by teachers and any job recruiter. It is a disease of our age. Another professor who is well known and wrote many books on social issues, was also criticized by her students who did not accept the theories she was presenting, the students could not provide alternative arguments to support their criticism. Intellectual laziness perhaps on their part.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s